@cgerrish @LisaKalayji
I think the point of the article is that it's not that, though. It's about the fact that allowing the question is already a privacy violation. There needs be no agreement where there is no question.
This was said well by John Gilmore in his speech at the First Conference on Computers, Freedom and Privacy in 1991, which I was lucky to attend. It was an amazing event, and one I quote often. The whole speech, which is not super-long, is worth reading, as it makes points similar to this article, but I'll excerpt the central part here for easier access, with a link to the fuller version at the bottom:
«There's been a lot of talk here about privacy ... but we haven't focused so much on why we want it. Privacy is a means; what is the real end that we are looking for here? I submit that what we're looking for _increased tolerance_.
Society tolerates all different kinds of behaviour -- differences in religion, differences in political opinions, races, etc. But if your differences aren't accepted by the government or by other parts of society, you can still be tolerated if they simply don't know that you are different. Even a repressive government or a regressive individual can't persecute you if you look the same as everybody else. And, as George Perry said today, "Diversity is the comparative advantage of American society". I think that's what privacy is really protecting.
The whole conference has spent a lot of time talking about ways to control uses of information and to protect peoples' privacy after the information was collected. But that only works if you assume a good government. If we get one seriously bad government, they'll have all the information they need to make an efficient police state and make it the last government. It's more than convenient for them -- in fact, it's a temptation for people who want to do that, to try to get into power and do it. Because we are giving them the means.
What if we could build a society where the information was never
collected?…»
Full talk: http://www.toad.com/gnu/cfp.talk.txt